Will Retargeting Destroy Hyperlocal Chain Models?

In my other life as a marketer/product manager, part of my role has been to dig into online advertising and learn about the technology in order to sell actual products. This has included in-depth research into click-through rates, ROI on different ads, sell-throughs, and all the other metrics that you read about on the advertising sites such as AdAge. Similarly, I learned a bit about PPC, SEM, Facebook ads, Twitter ads, and other forms of pay-for-performance online advertising. Probably the most disruptive technology to the ad market which I learned about was so-called retargeting. We loved it and I can understand why publishers hate it.

Retargeting is a simple concept. Say Salkever Enterprises sells high-end fishing gear. I want to serve display ads to people that I know are fisherman. In particular, I want to serve ads to people who visited FishingNews.com. I call up the FishingNews ad rep and they say, sure, we’ll sell you inventory at $25 CPM (cost per thousand impressions).

That’s steep for a little fishing company like mine. So I go to an advertising network and say, I want to serve ads against people who have visited fishing Websites. Can you help me out? They say sure, we can identify people who have recently visited fishing sites and serve them your display adds on other sites they are visiting that happen to run our inventory. And it will only cost you $1 CPM because we are selling remnant inventory these sites have sold to ad remnant networks. Even better, you’ll be able to follow your FishingNews readers all over the Internet!

This, in a nutshell, damages the economics of hyperlocal networks hoping to make any real ad revenues selling to larger buyers. These same buyers can – and increasingly do – use retargeting to get the same Internet users at a fraction of the cost. Retargeting also lets you perform nifty tricks like varying the types of ads a user might see depending on their past behavior or the number of times they have seen a spot.

Can it get annoying? Absolutely. I get tired of Zappos ads following me all over the Internet trying to sell me shoes. This becomes more of a problem when retargeters buy space on multiple remnant networks that don’t know what the other is doing. It can result in two or even three copies of the same ads running on the same Webpage at the same time. But at its very core, retargeting completely breaks down the exclusivity of advertising on Web property. For larger hyperlocal chains hoping to sell to larger regional and national advertisers, this means that they are selling against a radically cheaper cost alternative.

For mom-and-pop hyperlocals who are selling direct to merchants that want to support the publication, this is not as much of an issue. A local auto repair shop is probably not going to buy retargeted ads broken down by demographic and place as the number of addressable viewers per day would likely be too small to justify the hassle. In my mind, this is another example of how hyperlocal actually scales down better than it scales up. For bigger hyperlocal chains, the rise of retargeting will force them to be that much more creative about their advertising offerings and probably push them over time to move away from and even abandon straight display ad units.

Alex Salkever is an executive at a cloud computing company and a former technology editor of BusinessWeek.com. The views expressed in his column are his own and not those of his employer. His Personal Fight column appears every Wednesday on Street Fight.

Image courtesy of Flickr user Rob Ellis.


Street Fight Summit West is in just THREE weeks, and ticket prices are set to rise shortly. Join the top minds in hyperlocal in San Francisco on June 5th. Reserve your ticket today!

  1. May 16, 2012

    This is an immensely informative column that helps to explain why the loss of a dollar unit in print advertising often results in the gain of only a dime or even a penny unit on the Web.  I do hope, with Alex, that publishers will be able to outsmart this behavior that is turning so much Web advertising  into a grim bargain sub-basement. 

    1. May 17, 2012

      I agree, excellent article articulating why retargeting is bad for publishers even while most SMBs don’t buy ad networks. Thanks for sharing.

  2. benito
    May 17, 2012

    “For bigger hyperlocal chains, the rise of retargeting will force them
    to be that much more creative about their advertising offerings and
    probably push them over time to move away from and even abandon straight
    display ad units.”

    It’s perspective… I see it as another cheap offering to add to a hyperlocal or regional publishers offering to smb’s.  Many SMB’s don’t have the time or inclination to fuss with this.  The pitch would be something like this:

    “For this much more, we’ll manage a targeted remnant campaign for you across a variety of networks maximizing your brand’s awareness in the region… one monthly charge, one point of contact, no fuss.”

  3. Shelley Ellis
    May 17, 2012

    A savvy marketer can certainly find bargain basement deals for specific niches using PPC, display and retargeting. But…it’s worth it to pay the higher cost for niche specific media buys to get in front of a super targeted audience. I still like knowing that even the smallest company can find new customers online with their tiny budget and I don’t believe that larger companies are not going to stop doing media buys any time soon.

  4. May 18, 2012

    Alex, Great article. I do want to point out that with retargeting they should only be able to retarget people who visit the advertisers website not retarget people who they served an ad to on a publisher site. I know it happens but it is against just about every major networks terms to do so. This is more reason why publishers should wake up and stop letting their inventory leak to remnant networks.

  5. June 13, 2012

    The link in “hyperlocal actually scales down better than it scales up” goes to a blank document.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

How Location-Based Services Are Reinventing Radio