Too Many Local Journalists Are Missing The Big Story: Revenue | Street Fight

The New News

Too Many Local Journalists Are Missing The Big Story: Revenue

2 Comments 26 September 2013 by

money tunnelJournalists, bless them, are passionate creatures. They are committed to goals, issues and people that never have enough guardian angels — like fairness and justice, good government, the underdog. And, not least, freedom of the press.

In the new digital era, which requires journalists to widen their lens far beyond the next big story, they are beginning to channel their passion into how to engage users, embrace technology and examine the limitations of their traditional “Fourth Estate” role is in the community. All good. But there’s one area where journalists have yet to bring the full measure of their passion — revenue. There are bright spots (some of which were highlighted in my column last week), but overall journalism is just not focused enough on how to pay the bills.

The Reynolds Journalism Institute recently held a conference called “Five Years Past…Five Years Forward,” seeking to close the passion gap. There were more participants from journalism schools than print and digital publications, but it’s in the schools where future editors and publishers have to start seeing how their noblest aspirations depend on dollars (from advertising, subscriptions, events — somewhere) and learn the skills that will generate those dollars. The revenue roundtable included two experts who have been immersed in the digital space — Reade Brower, publisher of the Village Soup publications in Midcoast Maine, and Ron Blevins, VP of digital strategy at Novus Media, a subsidiary of the new ad conglomerate Omincom-Publicis that helps regional and national advertisers find customers through community-based sites (whose audiences may be micro-sized but are more engaged and therefore more likely to click to business messages). I was happy to be among those who helped put together the roundtabl, which was moderated by Pekka Pekkala, a research fellow in hyperlocal journalism at the University of Southern California Annenberg School of Journalism.

On the panel, Brower said “banner advertising alone just doesn’t cut it” at the local-hyperlocal level. His three Village Soup sites generate a total of $360,000 annually in “native” ads, where restaurants and retailers make announcements about specials they’re offering in four- or five-line self-published items. Because they’re self-published, the ads don’t require salespeople or production work. Brower’s Village Soup sites also have a modest pay wall — “8 cents a day,” as he likes to say. But 8 cents a day from the 5,000 subscribers adds up to $145,000 a year, or about $48,000 for each of the publications.

Blevins said community news sites should be cautious about moving too sweepingly with the trend toward content personalization. A prominent chunk of the homepage should consist of common content “on the key things the community needs to understand,” he said. Then, he went on, the rest of the page can be tailored to personalized content. The result, he said, is “you create a fan. You start to create an audience. That’s the number one thing in sustainability and monetization … creating a value proposition for the advertiser.”

Pekkala talked about the surprising conclusions he and his USC Annenberg research team reached after they looked at the ad programs of 10 hyperlocal news sites: “Business owners have to realize you are part of the business community,” he said. “Once they realize you’re doing good for the community by publishing news, they are willing to buy an ad. Once they do that, they don’t ask, ‘How many clicks did I get, or page views?’”

After the Sept. 9-10 conference was over, I asked Brower, Blevins and Pekkala whether they saw a spark of passion from participants during the revenue roundtable.

Brower: “I don’t think people are focused enough on revenues. People were open to discussions on revenue and sustainable models but I was disappointed not to get any direct feedback about the BizBriefs and the revenue they have created. The Village Soup platform could help a lot of [sites] and should at least be checked out by those who are looking for way through the tunnel.”

Blevins: “I thought there was engagement. However, I’m not sure they grasped the urgency with which local publishers need to act….Publishers should focus on what will enable them to tap into national ad dollars in the short-term while building out their value proposition and premium sales initiatives long term. Supply-side platforms [which can be automated to connect with ad exchanges looking for inventory for placement] are a good way to do this, but a lot of local publishers aren’t leveraging this tool. In short, they need a monetization strategy.”

Pekkala: “Journalists only see the newsroom, not the whole publication they work for….The
whole idea of revenue models is such a new thing for journalists in general and they have no tools, skills or even the language or discourse to talk about revenue streams or profits inside their own industry.”

Bill Densmore, an RJI consultant who helped organize “Five Years Forward,” summed up the dilemma diplomatically: “The history and culture of journalism has not integrated business thinking very well.”

There are so many new, often interlocking components of business thinking that have to be integrated into digital journalism: big data, social media, third-party ad exchanges, geo-location of the user and, increasingly, the user’s behavior right wherever she is at the moment.

It’s a Herculean task, and that’s why journalists have to bring their considerable passion to it.

Tom Grubisich authors The New News column for Street Fight. He is editorial director of LocalAmerica, which is partnering with InstantAtlas to develop sites that will present how communities rate in livability. Local America is featured on the Reynolds Journalism Institute’s Pivot Point site.

  • RickWaghorn

    Tom,

    Another timely read… And call to arms with regard to finding something that starts to move local independent publishers out of the mind-set of ‘not-for-profit’ to one of not-for-loss….

    With this first goal in mind, we launched our Public API at Ad:Tech (Tokyo) last week; specifically aiming at developers – be they on web or ever more increasingly mobile – who are seeking new and bespoke routes into the local ad marketplace.

    To requote Mr , now most definitely is the time to experiment, experiment, experiment….

  • West Seattle Blog

    (A) Yes, traditional advertising at this level DOES “cut it.” LOCAL advertising, NOT national advertising. Why in the WORLD do I want to junk up the space I offer to local businesses, by throwing national ads in there? They have enough other places to go. Local businesses do not.

    (B) Charging for news – which is what many business updates are, NEWS – can lead a reader to wonder, “well, is EVERYTHING I’m reading here because somebody’s paying for it?” As a publisher, I don’t think biznotes and event listings should be paid content. I also, heretically, don’t believe obituaries should be paid content either – it horrifies me that grieving families are ripped off to the tune of hundreds of dollars by “newspapers” large and small; we offer obits for free.

    Of course independent publishers need to think revenue; if you don’t, you can’t stay in business and you can’t serve your community. But I personally believe pundits have been way too quick to dismiss the power of simple online display advertising at this level.

Big Things Coming in Local in 2015!


Join us in New York, San Francisco and Denver for Street Fight's industry-leading conferences. Top speakers, great networking, valuable insights, and killer parties.
Click here for dates and details!

Newsletter

Get hyperlocal industry headlines in your inbox every morning. Subscribe to the Street Fight Daily newsletter.


See how brands compare in local presence across areas such as local SEO, data accuracy, social engagement and more. Presented by Where2GetIt and Street Fight. Click here to see the battle!

Free White Paper: Pay-Per-Call’s Role in Improving Marketing ROI

Call campaigns can make the phone ring — or alienate prospective customers. Learn how to get it right: Download "Pay-Per-Call's Role in Improving Marketing ROI."

Produced by Street Fight Insights for Soleo.

Free White Paper: Contextualization

Learn how to deliver better, revenue-driving consumer experiences. Download "Contextualization: Leveraging Location-Based Technology and Mobile to Drive Success for Brands."

Sponsored by Artisan Mobile.

Follow Us

Get the latest Street Fight news, information and analysis via Twitter and Facebook.

The Commerce Graph

The “Commerce Graph” is a new framework we have developed to think about the future of physical exchange. The model offers an alternative to the dominant narrative about the commerce landscape that frames digital networks as an adversary of physical exchange.

The $20 Billion Mobile Marketing Opportunity

Strategies and insights into the landscape of targeting options and how they deliver foot traffic and sales for SMBs.
Check out our 2013 report and get your copy today!

Twitter

© 2014 Street Fight.

Powered by WordPress. Hosting by Page.ly