Turf Talk

Daily Deals Biz: A Race to Own Local, Not Coupons?

0 Comments 24 October 2011 by

There seems to be a correlation between Groupon’s falling IPO target and the numbers of words journalists, non-journo-bloggers, pontificators, provocateurs and naysayers (and me) dedicate to the daily deals space. Hey, if we can call Social Security a Ponzi scheme why not the seemingly magical profit-machine of Groupon and others? OK, technically they are not profitable — damn close — but you get the point.

It’s difficult to get a handle on the deals space for several reasons. The incessant stream of contradictory stories coming from the media, in particular the online-only media where the focus is on generating a lot of content quickly is certainly an issue. Sometimes a reader is faced with a headline declaring the deals business is a fraud, local businesses hate and the end is near… in the same space hours later is another take with different facts declaring all’s well and everyone’s about to get richer. It can be maddenning to follow.

And what about the businesses trying to stretch their tiny marketing allotment in a particularly bad economy? Discounts are great for consumers of course but do businesses really see a recurring benefit or is it a one-time jolt, leaving them with half their stock gone at a quarter the take?

These are old concerns (arguments?) and it remains to be seen how all will pan out in the mid term. If you believe our own Alex Salkever there needs to be a shakeout:

We here at Street Fight and other media sources have been calling for a big consolidation in the daily deals market for some time now. But consolidation can take two forms. To date, that has been acquisitions. Going forward, there may be more outright closures. I discussed this a bit in a column about how the middle of the daily deal market would hollow out and small-time mom and pops would survive along with the big guys but not much in between.

So perhaps the scores of smaller deals sites will get gobbled up (as some already have, like Woot) or deflated. Certainly niche selling is an interesting trend, such as selling to moms by moms (Plum District) or delivering revenues for schools (FundsOn). But this too seems to be a means to a larger end.

I think we may be witnessing a race to see who can capture the consumer on his own time and his own turf — and his preferred context — with content (and deals) of specific interest to him a few moments before he realizes he wanted it. The daily deals are just a foot in the door to the broader hyperlocal market. With mobile fully established as a viable means for communicating with customers wherever they are (and for them to express themselves in kind) this race is only more obvious. If you think the end game of Groupon and LivingSocial and their aggressive cousins is to sell coupons I think you’ve not been paying close enough attention.

Whatever territory and mindshare the likes of Patch have, Goup-Social wants.

All this will be chewed on in my panel session at the Street Fight Summit tomorrow, October 25. Key to finding answers will be my guests, Jonty Kelt, CEO, Group Commerce (formerly of DoubleClick); Chad Billmyer, CEO of Dealbird (formerly Petersons.com and StudentEdge.com); and Perry Evans, CEO of Closely (former lead on development of MapQuestJabber and Local Matters).

I imagine they may rip up my assumptions, which would be entertaining but more important I think they’ll offer informed opinions on where we’ll be in five years and how you, dear reader, might profit.

Or maybe we’ll just gripe about Groupon.

Rick Robinson’s Turf Talk column appears every Wednesday on Street Fight. Follow him @Loclly

Join top hyperlocal execs for strategy, ideas and networking. Register today!

Newsletters

Get hyperlocal headlines in your box every morning with Street Fight Daily. For financial analysis and the market potential of hyperlocal businesses, subscribe to The Hyperlocal Investment Report.

Street Fight Insights: ‘The Local Merchant’

Street Fight's white paper research report is a playbook for anyone looking to succeed in the hyperlocal marketing ecosystem. Combining research from over 50 interviews with expert analysis, the report provides key insight into an exploding market opportunity. Buy your copy today!

Follow Us

Get the latest Street Fight news, information and analysis via Twitter and Facebook.

Why Check In?

“I did not want to be mayor of my dentist’s office. Why did I even check in?” wondered Digital First Media's Steve Buttry in a recent tweet. Street Fight's David Hirschman takes a look at check-in services from a consumer perspective, and tries to figure out why we feel so compelled to use services like Foursquare.

Sponsored Post: Improving Online Offers

Although couponing has gained mainstream acceptance, coupons have proven an inefficient way to redeem an offer. In a new white paper OfferWise offers guidance on integrating mobile and in-store experiences; creating trackability; and thrilling shoppers.

Facebook Connect & Local

Where Facebook starts to get "spooky powerful" is in its capability to deliver local ads to a Facebook Connect network that will be personalized and reflect the actions, comments, likes and dislikes of your friends.. This will tap into a recognizable social graph as Facebook seeks to do – and it could turn into an extremely lucrative, higher CPC line of business.

The ‘Twisted Thinking’ Behind SMB Self-Service

Closely CEO Perry Evans unpacks the ideas behind attempts to create self-service platforms for SMBs to place online ads: "Technology comfort alone will not drive scaled merchant participation."

Twitter

© 2012 Street Fight.

Powered by WordPress. Hosting by Page.ly